Privy Council Office
Home Contacts Feedback Sitemap Links Freedom of Information Text only Search
Judgments
 

Index of 2001 Judgments

Notes: (1) Judgments in devolution cases are separately listed at the end of this index.
          (2) Italics indicate that the judgment is an Advance copy, still subject to minor amendments.
          (3) As from 2001, Privy Council judgments bear the neutral citation:- [Year] UKPC [no.]

No. Case Names Origin Date of Judgment
1 The Commissioner of Inland Revenue v. Auckland Harbour Board (Appeal No. 30 of 2000)   New Zealand 24th January 2001
2 (1) Krishna Jairam (2) Ramsingh Persad v.The State (Appeal No. 4 of 2000) Trinidad and Tobago 24th January 2001
3 Herbert Ferguson v. The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago (Appeal No. 11 of 2000) Trinidad and Tobago 24th January 2001
4 George Moore v. The State (Appeal No. 7 of 2000) Trinidad and Tobago 29th January 2001
5 Anthony John Snell v. Mrs Margaret Beadle (nee Silcock) (Appeal No. 19 of 2000) Jersey 29th January 2001
6 (1) G J Cleaver and (2) Naul Bodden v. Delta American Reinsurance Company (Appeal No. 5 of 2000) Cayman Islands 1st February 2001
7 Lascelles Augustus Chin v. Audrey Ramona Chin (Appeal No. 61 of 1999) Jamaica 12th February 2001
8 (1) John Benjamin (2) Mildred Vanderpool and (3) Sidney Gumbs v. The Hon. Minister of Information and Broadcasting and (2) The Attorney General for Anguilla (Appeal No. 2 of 1999) Anguilla 14th February 2001
9 Dilworth Trust Board v. (1) Counties Manukau Health Limited and (2) Her Majesty's Attorney-General (Appeal No. 13 of 2000) New Zealand 7th March 2001
10 (1) The Contradictors v. (1) The Attorney General of New Zealand (2) The Public Trustee and (1) Marion Anne Pritchard and (2) Barbara Joan Wright v. (1) The Attorney General of New Zealand (2) The Public Trustee New Zealand 8th March 2001
11 Observer Publications Limited v. (1) Campbell "Mickey" Matthew (2) The Commissioner of Police and (3) The Attorney General (Appeal No. 3 of 2000) Antigua and Barbuda 19th March 2001
12 Robert Smalling v. The Queen (Appeal No. 45 of 2000) Jamaica 20th March 2001
13 Dr Narumanchi Sai Baba v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 16 0f 2000) Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 22nd March 2001
14 (1) Valentines Properties Limited and (2) (Valentines Restaurant and Bar (NZ) Limited v. (1) Huntco Corporation Limited and (2) Steeple Transport Holdings (1993) Limited (Appeal No.38 of 2000) New Zealand 29th March 2001
15 Dr Marta Stefan v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 72 of 2000) The Health Committee of the GMC 5th April 2001
16 Marion Lorde (Administratrix of the Estate of Desmond Cave, deceased) v. The Transport Board (Appeal No.27 of 2000) Barbados 29th March 2001
17 (1) Brian Andrew O'Neil (2) Moira O'Neil (3) Lyndon Lee McDougall and (4) John James McDougall v. Commissioner of Inland Revenue (Appeal No. 40 of 2000) New Zealand 10th April 2001
18 (1) Raylee Patricia Harley v. Robert McDonald (2) Glasgow Harley v. Robert McDonald (Appeal Nos. 9 of 2000 and 50 of 2000) New Zealand 10th April 2001
19 Forrester Bowe (Junior) v. The Queen (Appeal No. 48 of 2000) The Bahamas 10th April 2001
20 Ann Marie Boodram v. The State (Appeal No. 65 of 2000) Trinidad and Tobago 10th April 2001
21 (1) Robert Mohammed and (2) Johnny Richardson v. The State (Appeal No 60 of 2000) Trinidad and Tobago 10th April 2001
22 Dr Ramesh Kumar Gulati v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 73 of 2000) Professional Conduct Committee of The GMC 5th April 2001
23 Wrightson Limited v. Fletcher Challenge Nominees Limited (Appeal No. 34 of 2000) New Zealand 3rd May 2001
24 Samy Sunnassee v. David Ardill (Appeal No. 50 of 1999) Mauritius 21st May 2001
25 Goomti Ramnarace v. Harrypersad Lutchman (Appeal No. 8 of 2000) Trinidad and Tobago 21st May 2001
26 Norman Shaw v. The Queen (Appeal No.58 of 2000) Belize 24th May 2001
27 Cleon Smith v. The Queen (Appeal No.59 of 2000) Belize 24th May 2001
28 (1) Richard Dale Agnew and (2) Kevin James Bearsley v. (1) The Commissioner of Inland Revenue and (2) Official Assignee for the estate in bankruptcy of Bruce William Birtwhistle and Mark Leslie Birtwhistle (Appeal No.35 of 2000) New Zealand 5th June 2001
29 Dr. Purabi Ghosh v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 69 of 2000) Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 18th June 2001
30 Jennifer Gairy (as administratrix of the estate of Eric Matthew Gairy, deceased) v. The Attorney General of Grenada (Appeal No. 29 of 2000) Grenada 19th June 2001
31 Michael Yearwood v. The Queen (Appeal No. 75 of 2000) Grenada 26th June 2001
32 Manukau Urban Maori Authority and Others v. Treaty of Waitangi Fisheries Commission and Others and Reuben Brian Perenara v. Treaty of Waitangi Fisheries Commission and Others (Consolidated Appeals Nos. 67 and 68 of 2000) New Zealand 2nd July 2001
33 (1) Donald Panton and (2) Janet Panton v. (1) The Minister of Finance and (2) The Attorney General (Appeal No. 20 of 2000) Jamaica 12th July 2001
34 (1) The Bay Hotel and Resort Limited and (2) Zurich Indemnity Company of Canada v. (1) Cavalier Construction Co. Ltd. and (2) Cavalier Construction Co. Ltd (a Turks and Caicos Islands Registered Company) (Appeal No. 32 0f 2000) Turks and Caicos Islands 16th July 2001
35 Newton Spence v. The Queen (Appeal No. 47 of 2000) St. Vincent and the Grenadines 16th July 2001
36 David Preiss v. The General Dental Council (Appeal No. 63 of 2000) Professional Conduct Committee of the GDC 17th July 2001
37 (1) Andre Bennett and (2) Augustus John v. The Queen (Appeal No. 74 of 2000) Grenada 17th July 2001
38 Confessor Valdez Franco v. The Queen (Appeal No. 70 of 2000) Antigua and Barbuda 14th August 2001
39 Dr. Sebastian Anthony Borges v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 71 of 2000) Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 12th July 2001
Reasons given 31st August 2001 
40 Dr. Mahmood Hossain v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 77 of 2000) Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 2nd October 2001
41 Berthill Fox v. The Queen (Appeal No. 66 of 2000) St Christopher and Nevis 2nd October 2001
42 Dr Willem Bijl v. The General Medical Council(Appeal No. 78 of 2000) Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 2nd October 2001
43 (1) M.A. McGuire and (2) F.P. Makea v. (1) Hastings District Council and (2) The Maori Land Court of New Zealand (Appeal No. 43 of 2000) New Zealand 1st November 2001
44 Dr Shiv Prasad Dey v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 19 of 2001) Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 6th November 2001
45 Mrs. Paula Carroll v. The Council for Professions Supplementary to Medicine (Radiographers Board) (Appeal No. 15 of 2001) The Professions Supplementary to Medicine Act 1960 6th November 2001
46 Dr. Anthony Peter Hall v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No.25 of 2001) The Health Committee of the GMC 7th November 2001
47 Dr. John Harding Price v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 3 of 2001) Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 7th November 2001
48 Dr Sivagurunathan Srirangalingham v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 46 of 2001) Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 12th November 2001
49 Dr. Abdul Baten Jalal Ahmed v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 5 of 2001) Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 19th November 2001
50 Dextra Bank & Trust Company Limited v. Bank of Jamaica (Appeal No. 26 of 2000) Jamaica 26th November 2001
51 Kena Kena Properties Limited v. The Attorney General (Appeal No.44 of 2000) New Zealand 27th November 2001
52 (1) Leslie Cook (2) Winifred Cook v. Norlands Limited (Appeal No.51 of 2000) Isle of Man 27th November 2001
53 Dougnath Rajkumar v. Kenneth Lalla and others (Appeal No. 1 of 2001) Trinidad and Tobago 29th November 2001
54 The Commissioner of Inland Revenue v. Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Limited (Appeal No. 64 of 2000) New Zealand 4th December 2001
55 Dr Khan Mohammed Anis-Uddin Manzur v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 24 of 2001) Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 4th December 2001
56 Richard Hinds v. (1) The Attorney General and (2) The Superintendent of Glendairy Prison (Appeal No. 28 0f 2000) Barbados 5th December 2001
57 (1) John Andrew Bagnall and (2) Andrew John Maher v. Mobil Oil New Zealand Limited (Appeal No.23 of 2001) New Zealand 11th December 2001
58 Jeanette Walsh (as executrix of the estate of David G. Walsh) and Others v. Deloitte & Touche Inc., Trustee of the estate of Bre-X Minerals Limited., a bankrupt (Appeal No. 37 of 2000) Bahamas 17th December 2001
59 (1) Colin Joseph Brazier and (2) Brazier Scaffolding Limited. v. (1) Bramwell Scafolding (Dunedin) Limited (2) Bruce Leonard Harvey and (3) Bramwell Scaffolding Limited (Appeal No. 7 of 2001) New Zealand 18th December 2001
60 Dr. Kandukuri Anjaneyulu v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 49 0f 2001) The Health Committee of the GMC 19th December 2001
61 Dr. Prabha Gupta v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 44 of 2001) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 18th December 2001
Reasons given 21st December 2001

 Judgments in Devolution Cases

No. Case Names Origin Date of Judgment
D1 (1) Her Majesty's Advocate and (2) Her Majesty's Advocate General for Scotland v. Robert McIntosh (DRA No. 12 of 2000) High Court of Justiciary (Scotland) 5th February 2001
D2 Gary Follen v. Her Majesty's Advocate (DP1 of 2001) High Court of Justiciary (Scotland) 8th March 2001
D3 (1) Norman McLean and (2) Peter McLean v. (1) Procurator Fiscal, Fort William and (2) Her Majesty's Advocate General (DRA No.4 of 2000) High Court of Justiciary (Scotland) 24th May 2001
D4 (1) David Cameron Millar v. Procurator Fiscal, Elgin and (2) Kerry Payne (3) Paul Stewart and (4) Joseph Tracey v. Procurator Fiscal, Dundee (DRA Nos. 5, 6, 7, and 8 of 2000) High Court of Justiciary (Scotland) 24th July 2001
D5 (1) Karl Anderson (2) Alexander Reid and (3) Brian Doherty v. (1) The Scottish Ministers and (2) Advocate General for Scotland (DRA Nos. 9, 10 and 11 of 2000) Inner House of the Court of Session (Scotland) 15th October 2001

Note: Numbers in italics indicate that the judgment is an Advance copy, still subject to minor amendments.

Print
Related Issues
 Judgments
 In this Section
Judicial Committee
Judgments
Appeal Statistics