Privy Council Office
Home Contacts Feedback Sitemap Links Freedom of Information Text only Search
Judgments
 

Index of 2002 Judgments

Notes: (1) Judgments in devolution cases are separately listed at the end of this index.
          (2) Italics indicate that the judgment is an Advance copy, still subject to minor amendments.
          (3) As from 2001, Privy Council judgments bear the neutral citation:- [Year] UKPC [no.]

No. Case names Origin Date of judgment
1. Rosie Blanchfield and others v. (1) The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago and (2) Chaguaramas Development Authority (1) Yvonne Cross and (2) Wilhemina Hoyte v. (1) The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago and (2) Chaguaramas Development Authority (Appeal Nos. 61 and 62 of 2000) Trinidad and Tobago 22nd January 2002
2. Universal Leasing and Finance Limited v. Montego Vacations Limited (Appeal No. 33 of 2000) Jamaica 24th January 2002
3. Marvin Murphy v. The Queen (Appeal No. 34 of 2001) The Bahamas 31st January 2002
4. Christchurch Pavilion Partnership No.1 and Others v. Deloitte & Touche Tohmatsu Trustee Company Limited (Appeal No.16 of 2001) New Zealand 4th February 2002
5. Thakur Persad Jaroo v. The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago (Appeal No. 54 of 2000) Trinidad and Tobago 4th February 2002
6. Dr Thomas Amadeus Keiran Norton v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 77 of 2001) Medical Act 1983 11th February 2002
7. Leonard Ogilvy v. The Minister of Legal Affairs (Reasons for a decision upon a Notice of Motion) St Lucia 17th January 2002 Reasons given 13th February 2002
8. Ancare New Zealand Limited v. (1) Fort Dodge New Zealand and (2) Nufarm Limited (Appeal No. 32 of 2001) New Zealand 6th February 2002 Reasons given 28th February 2002
9. (1) G.J. Hamilton and (2) M.P. Hamilton v. (1) Papakura District Council and (2) Watercare Services Ltd. (Appeal No. 57 of 2000) New Zealand 28th February 2002
10. Dr Marta Stefan v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 92 of 2001) The Health Committee of the GMC 6th March 2002
11. Patrick Reyes v. The Queen (Appeal No.64 of 2001) Belize 11th March 2002
12. The Queen v. Peter Hughes (Appeal No.91 of 2001) St. Lucia 11th March 2002
13. Berthill Fox v. The Queen (Appeal No. 66 of 2000) Saint Christopher and Nevis 11th March 2002
14. (1) Michael Adams and (2) Frederick Lawrence v. The Queen (Appeal No. 14 of 2001) Jamaica 18th March 2002
15. Fa'afete Taito v. The Queen and James McLeod Bennett and 10 others v. The Queen (Consolidated Appeals) (Appeal Nos. 50 and 59 of 2001) New Zealand 19th March 2002
16. (1) CVC/Opportunity Equity Partners Limited and (2) Opportunity Invest II Limited v. Luis Roberto Demarco Almeida (Appeal No. 4 of 2001) Cayman Islands 21st March 2002
17. The Queen v. Rennie Gilbert (Appeal No. 10 of 2001) Grenada 21st March 2002
18. The Attorney General for the Cayman Islands v. Carlyle Rudyard Roberts (Appeal No. 53 0f 2001) Cayman Islands 21st March 2002
19. Barry Victor Randall v. The Queen (Appeal No. 22 of 2001) Cayman Islands 16th April 2002
20. Felix Augustus Durity v. The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago (Appeal No. 52 0f 2000) Trinidad and Tobago 13th May 2002
21. Clinton Forbes v. The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago (Appeal No. 2 of 2001) Trinidad and Tobago 15th May 2002
22. Dr. Narumanchi Sai Baba v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No.70 of 2001) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 15th May 2002
23. Philip Joshua Rahming v. The Queen (Appeal No. 33 0f 2001) Bahamas Bahamas 4th December 2001 Reasons given 20th May 2002
24. Half Moon Bay Limited v. Crown Eagle Hotels Limited (Appeal No. 31 of 2000) Jamaica 20th May 2002
25. Progressive Enterprises Limited v. (1) Foodstuffs (Auckland) Limited and (2) The Commerce Commission (Appeal No. 6 of 2002) New Zealand 23rd May 2002 Reasons given 29th April 2002
26. Union Bank of Jamaica Limited v. Dalton Yap (Appeal No. 17 of 2001) Jamaica 28th May 2002
27. Lloyds TSB Bank plc v. (1) Paul Frederick Clarke (Liquidator of Socimer International Bank Limited) and (2) Chase Manhattan Bank Luxembourg S.A. (Appeal No. 41 of 2001) Bahamas Reasons given 29th May 2002
28. (1) Man O''War Station Limited and (2) Huruhe Station Limited v. (1) Auckland City Council (formerly Waiheke County Council) and (2) H.M. Attorney General for New Zealand (Judgment No. 1) (Appeal No. 21 of 2001) New Zealand 7th May 2002 Reasons given 29th May 2002
29. Leslie Tiwari v. The State (Appeal No. 76 of 2001) Trinidad and Tobago 29th May 2002
30. Kinoo Sons Limited v. (1) Mrs Bibi Sarah Hossen Abdool and (2) The Conservator of Mortgages (Appeal No. 55 of 2001) Mauritius 11th June 2002
31. Hugh Bonnick v. (1) Margaret Morris (2) The Gleaner Company Ltd. and (3) Ken Allen (Appeal No. 30 of 2001) Jamaica 17th June 2002
32. (1) Man O'War Station Limited and (2) Huruhe Station Limited v. Auckland County Council (formerly Waiheke County Council) and (2) H.M. Attorney General for New Zealand (Judgment No. 2) (Appeal No. 21 of 2001) New Zealand 17th June 2002
33. (1) Noel Heath (2) Charles Miller and (3) Glenroy Matthew v. THe Government of the United States of America (Appeal No. 6 of 2001) Saint Christopher and Nevis 19th June 2002
34. Herbert Charles v. (1) The Judicial and Legal Service Commission and (2) The Disciplinary Tribunal (Appeal No. 34 of 2001) Trinidad and Tobago 20th May 2002 Reasons for decision 19th June 2002
35. Dr John Adrian Garfoot v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 81 0f 2001) Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 2nd May 2002 Reasons for Report 19th June 2002
36.

Dr. Leonard Mark Marinovich v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 100 of 2001)

Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 24th June 2002
37. Dr. Mohamed Shaker Haikel v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 69 of 2001) Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 4th July 2002
38. (1) Nicholas Reda (2) Jamal Abdul-Jalil v. Flag Limited (Appeal No. 63 of 2001) Bermuda 11th July 2002
39. (1) Derrick Burgess (2) Chris Furbert (3) Sinclair Smith (4) Orin Simmons v. Stevedoring Services Limited (Appeal No. 37 of 2001) Bermuda 15th July 2002
40. Canterbury Golf International Limited v. Hideo Yoshimoto (Appeal No. 99 of 2001) New Zealand 15th July 2002
41.

Dr Maya Chaudhury v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 78 of 2001)

Committee on Professional Performance of the GMC  15th July 2002
42. (1) Gaetan Seneque and (2) Jacques David v. The Director of Public Prosecutions (Appeal No. 43 of 2001) Mauritius 24th July 2002
43.

Kirvek Management and Consulting Services Limited v. The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago (Appeal No. 52 of 2001)

Trinidad and Tobago 25th July 2002
44.

A v. Bottrill
(as amended on 13 September 2002. All versions downloaded prior to this date should be replaced) (Appeal No. 10 of 2002)

New Zealand

9 July 2002
Reasons for Report 6th September 2002

45 Elizabeth Morag Crabbie v. The General Medical Council  (Appeal No. 7 of 2002) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC

11th July 2002 Reasons for Report 23rd September 2002

46 Prince Pinder v. The Queen (Appeal No. 40 of 2001) The Bahamas 15th July 2002 Reasons for Report 23rd September 2002
47 (1) Rodney District Council (2) Manukau City Council (3) Hutt City Council and (4) New Zealand Local Government Association Incorporated (Appeal No. 29 of 2001) New Zealand 7th October 2002
48

Geest plc v. Monica Lansiquot (Appeal No. 27 of 2001)

St. Lucia 10th July 2002 Reasons 7th October 2002
49 Rodney David Haines  v. Lynne Valerie Carter (Appeal No. 75 of 2001)
New Zealand 7th October 2002
50 Dymocks Franchise Systems (NSW) Pty. Limited  v. (1) John Todd and Alicia B. Todd
(2) Bilgola Enterprises Ltd. and (3) Lambton Quay Books Ltd.
(Appeal No. 8 of 2001)
New Zealand 7th October 2002
51 Eric Llewellyn Jemmott v. The Commissioner of Police (Appeal No. 18 of 2001) Grenada 22nd July 2002 Reasons 14th October 2002
52 (1) Kizza Sealey and (2) Marvin Headley v. The State (Appeal No. 98 0f 2001) Trinidad and Tobago 14th October 2002
53 (1) Clifton Shaw (2) Titus Henry (3) Morris Boreland (4) Donovan Mullings and (5) Junior Wright (Appeal No. 67 0f 2001)  Jamaica 15th October 2002
54 Dr. Christopher Dare v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 19 0f 2002) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 11th July 2002 Reasons for Report 16th October 2002
55 Dr. Tushar Kanti Bhadra v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 12 of 2001) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 17th July 2002 Reasons for Report 22nd October 2002
56 Dr. Sampige Nanjundiah Sreenath v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 26 of 2002) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 3rd October 2002 Reasons for Report 23rd October 2002
57 Steven James Walker v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 94 of 2001) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 14th October 2002 Reasons for Report 5th November 2002
58

(1) Mark Sangster and (2) Randall Dixon v. The Queen (Appeal No. 8 of 2002)

Jamaica 7th October 2002 Reasons for Report 6th November 2002
59 Rokas Karpavicius v. The Queen (Appeal No. 14 of 2002) New Zealand 11th November 2002
60 (1) Myron Goldfinger and (2) Cove Castles Development Corporation v. Norman Luxemburg (Appeal No. 95 of 2001) Anguilla 11th November 2002
61 Dr. Anthony Peter Hall v.The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 24 of 2002) The Health Committee of the GMC 14th November 2002
62 Dr. Timothy David Whitefield v.The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 90 of 2001) The Health Committee of the GMC 14th November 2002
63

Vinode Jhagroo v. The Teaching Service Commission  (Appeal No. 35 of 2001)

Trinidad and Tobago 4th December 2002
64 Dr. Ramachandran Subramanian v.The General Medical Council   (Appeal No. 16 of 2002) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 5th December 2002
65 Dr. Narasinga Mukunda Rao v.The General Medical Council   (Appeal No. 21 of 2002) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 9th December 2002
66 Commercial Innovation Bank Alfa Bank v. Victor Kozeny a.k.a. Viktor Kozeny (Appeal No. 5 of 2002) The Bahamas 11th December 2002
67 Lutchman Ramcoomarsingh v. The Administrator General  (Appeal No. 13 of 2001) Trinidad and Tobago 16th December 2002
68 John A. Charles v. Yvette Barzey (Appeal No. 11 of 2002) Dominica 19th December 2002
69 Shanti Matadeen (in substitution for Suresh Matadeen, deceased) v. Caribbean Insurance Co Limited (Appeal No. 46 of 1999) Trinidad and Tobago 19th December 2002

Judgments in Devolution Cases

No. Case names Origin Date of Judgment
D1 Procurator Fiscal, Linlithgow v. (1) John Watson and (2) Paul Burrows Her Majesty's Advocate v. JK (DRA. Nos.1 and 2 of 2001) The High Court of Justiciary 29th January 2002
D2

Kenneth Anthony Paton Mills   v.                              (1) (Her Majesty's Advocate and (2) The Advocate General for Scotland    (DRA No. 1 of 2002)

The High Court of Justiciary 22nd July 2002
D3

"R" v.  (1) Her Majesty's Advocate and (2) The Advocate General for Scotland (DRA.No. 3 0f 2002)

The High Court of Justiciary 28th November 2002

 

Note: Italics indicate that the judgment is an Advance copy, still subject to minor amendments.

Print
Related Issues
 Judgments
 In this Section
Judicial Committee
Judgments
Appeal Statistics